Teary-Eyed Evolution: Crying Serves A Purpose : NPR
Basically, it seems the gist of the argument here is the following line:
Scientists who study evolution say crying probably conferred some benefit and did something to advance our species — because it’s stayed with us.
Wow – that is like straight out of the adaptationist playbook. The problem with this argument is that many things exist and persist in organisms even when they are not adaptive. There are many reasons why this can happen from constraints (e.g., if bones were not adaptive in humans it would be pretty hard to get rid of them) to invisibility to selection (e.g., some features that only show up after reproductive age may not really influence fitness) and so on.
In essence the NPR story is one of the worst examples of adaptationism in the good science press I have seen in a while. Sure this shows up all over the place. But rarely this bad at NPR. The story ends with an even worse line than the rest
Maybe that’s another reason evolution kept humans weeping: Tears help reveal the truth. And that’s because along with the tears, we’ve evolved a very sophisticated ability to interpret them.
Yes that is right. Crying has been maintained in humans because we also evolved another adaptive feature – the ability to interpret tears. So the logic here is that crying is adaptive because it is needed for another adaptive trait for which there is no evidence it is adaptive.
So for their story on crying and for in essence inventing some just so stories to explain why they think it is adaptive, NPR is the recipient of my Twisted Tree of Life Award. Previous recipients are
- Twisted tree of life award #6: Scientific American Origins piece for dissing microbes
- Twisted tree of life award #5: Nicholas Wade & use of higher, lower, ladders, etc
- Twisted Tree of Life Award #4: Hoxful Monsters Blog on “Primitive” Animals
- Twisted Tree of Life Award #3: The Columbus Dispatch on Ancient Bacteria
- Twisted Tree of Life Award #2: Science Friday on the Five Kingdoms
- Twisted Tree of Life Award #1: Salk Institute Press Release on Kinases
See also these things for some stuff on evolution of crying:
- Darwin in the Crib – oldie but goodie from Carl Zimmer in 2005
- Zimmer’s NY Times article related to the above.
- A Critique of the Adaptationist Programme from Larry Moran at Sandwalk
- My Evolution textbook has some discussion of
2 thoughts on “Twisted Tree of Life Award: NPR on the Evolution of Crying”
“did something to advance our species”
wow – did not even notice that within the quote